
My father suffered from Parkinson’s Disease for many years, managing it well for a long time, but it eventually took its toll. When he was in his late 80s, and I in my late 40s, I was staying with him, helping him—as much as he would let me—with personal care.
One afternoon, as I was helping him out of the shower, I noticed that his toenails were very long, curling over the tips of his toes.
“Dad, how about you let me cut your toenails? They’ve gotten pretty long.”
He replied, “Oh, you don’t need to bother yourself with that.”
“I know, but I’m sure it’s getting harder for you to reach down there.”
“It’s not that, it’s just that I can’t hold my hands steady enough to cut them myself.”
“I understand, that’s why I offered. Since you just showered, they will be soft and easy for me to cut.”
After more back and forth, he relented. We went into his bedroom, and I asked him to lie down on his bed so I could sit next to him to cut them. Once again, he fussed that he disliked having to burden me and others with helping him with personal care.
I finally said, “When we were kids, we always complained that you were impossible to buy presents for because you always said you didn’t need anything. We hated that, because it feels good to give someone a present. I want to give you this as a present. Can you let me do this?”
With that he let go, and what ensued was one of the warmest times I ever spent with my father. I sat and held his feet, and he relaxed completely. I cut his toenails while we talked about other matters. When I was done he told me how much he appreciated that, and we shared a long hug.
◊
Not long after this, I told this story to a friend who is an evangelical Christian, and he replied, “The Lord loves a good receiver.” The phrase really rang my bell. We (not just Christians) have become so deeply ingrained in the teaching that “it is better to give than to receive” that we fail to recognize that every act of giving requires a receiver. This same phrase can often imply moral superiority—givers are simply better people than receivers. No wonder we take pride not only in acts of charity but also in self-sufficiency. Taken to its logical extreme, “it is best to give freely and accept nothing.”
This dynamic isn’t uniquely, or even particularly, Christian. Honor cultures around the world hold that to accept a gift is to become indebted to the giver, and that the best way to respond is to reciprocate with a gift even more valuable or extravagant. If one lacks the means to do so, it’s best to avoid receiving the gift in the first place. This is generally about social position and power—the Christian “contribution” is to add a moral dimension, so that receiving a gift we cannot return can feel like moral failure.
Jesus, however, says it’s not like that at all (as he does so often in response to dysfunctional religiosity). That being a receiver is not a bad thing—in fact it’s essential. In the story of washing the feet of his disciples at the Last Supper,[1] Jesus more or less commands Peter to be a good receiver. He also says that we “ought to wash one another’s feet,” using language that is completely mutual—there is neither giver or receiver, we are to be both at all times.
This makes me think twice when I find myself saying “I don’t really need anything” when asked what I might like for my birthday or the holidays. I realize now how much better it feels to the other person for me to instead answer, “Here is something I would really like to receive from you.” Similarly, instead of asking “What do you want?” it feels much more inviting to ask, “What might you like to receive from me?” It’s a simple reframing, but it feels very different.
I think about this in the context of my own aging, and that of friends and family around my age (or older). Most of the generation ahead of me is no longer here to offer care to, and as our own physical (and cognitive) capacity declines, we increasingly benefit from help from others. At first it might be simple things like accepting rides at night or a hand going up steps, or learning new technologies, but over time our needs become more complex (moving out of a home, preparing meals, cutting toenails). We can reject help and rage against our declining self-sufficiency, or we can be good receivers, blessing others with the opportunity to be of service to us—a gift to both giver and receiver.
If I am fated to follow an aging trajectory similar to my father’s, I want to remember that, as much as I treasure my ability to live independently and to serve others, at some point the greatest gift I can offer others is to let go and to be a good receiver of their love and care. In truth, the time is coming, indeed it is already here—how will I respond?
[1] John 13:3-20 (selections) – Jesus rose from the supper table, took off his outer garment and, taking a towel, tied it around his waist. Then he poured water into a basin, and began to wash his disciples’ feet, and to wipe them with the towel.
When he came to Simon Peter, Peter said to him, “I will never let you wash my feet.”
“If I do not wash you,” Jesus replied, “you have no part with me.”
“Then, Lord,” said Simon Peter, “not my feet only; wash my hands and head as well!”
After he had washed their feet, [Jesus] said to them … 14 “If I, your Lord and Teacher, have washed your feet, so you also ought to wash one another’s feet.”